Middlebury is located in Elkhart between Elkhart and Shipshewana along US Highway 120 and State Highway 13. Middlebury is near the Elkhart River and the Michigan/Indiana border.
The population estimate for July 1, 1998 was 2,359, an increase of 355 since 1990.
Middlebury is part of the Elkhart-Goshen, Indiana metro area.
